“How to Save Your IRA from Destruction”
January 1st, 2009
Naming a trust as the designated beneficiary of your IRA has several very important advantages over directly naming the beneficiaries. First, the beneficiary may be a minor, not prudent with money, have marital or creditor issues, or may be disabled. Second, if the beneficiary dies before distribution, the contingent beneficiaries may not be correct. Third, the beneficiary may intentionally or unintentionally withdraw the IRA. In addition, naming the client’s revocable living trust as the beneficiary, even with the appropriate “conduit-trust” language, may create issues with the age of beneficiaries in order to “stretch-out” the required minimum distributions. In 2005, the IRS issued Private Letter Ruling 200537044 (the “PLR”) that approved a new type of revocable trust created solely to be the beneficiary of an IRA account. As a result of this PLR, it is now possible for you to create a stand-alone trust which provides maximum protection and flexibility.
This IRA Beneficiary Trust® insures that your beneficiaries (those who will receive the IRA’s after your departure) “stretch-out” their taxable, required minimum IRA distributions over a much longer period of time; with this trust, the age of each beneficiary becomes the operative age for that beneficiary’s required minimum distribution. And, if you do it right, the IRAs can continue to compound for many years income-tax free - - and may literally grow to be worth millions of dollars! This type of trust is also called an IRA trust, an IRA Inheritance Trust, a standalone IRA trust, an IRA stretch trust or an IRA protection trust.
When your children and grandchildren inherit your IRA funds and they keep the funds in the IRA over their lives and only take the required minimum distributions each year (the “stretch-out”), the amount of money that can be earned, accumulated and paid to them can be staggering. To illustrate how this compounding works, assume your beneficiary receives a $100,000 IRA account; If we use two different ages (10 and 35) for the beneficiary and assume that the account averages an annualized 8% return: for the beneficiary who is age 35 at the client’s death, the total benefit is $1,228,630 and for the 10 year old beneficiary, the total benefit is $5,363,512!
This wealth accumulation strategy only works if the beneficiaries retain the inherited funds inside the IRA account. If a beneficiary takes all of the funds out of the IRA account (called a “blow-out” because it blows the stretch-out), this wealth accumulation technique will be lost. One of the reasons to create an IRA Beneficiary Trust® is because it can insure the stretch-out and can prevent a blow-out. This blow-out happens way too often and jeopardizes planning that could have been saved. The beneficiaries may not be aware of the tax rules and their distribution choices, so they may immediately withdraw the IRA’s at the first opportunity (or worse yet, do a prohibited rollover!). Or the beneficiary, often influenced by his or her spouse, just decides to withdraw the IRA’s to spend it foolishly. If the “stretch-out” isn’t done properly by the beneficiaries and income taxes are paid up front shortly after the IRA’s are inherited, you and your family could lose hundreds of thousands of dollars (or more). Even if you assume that your children or beneficiaries will do the right thing – that is, keep the funds in the IRA account for their lives to maximize the income tax “stretch-out” of the IRA – the IRA may still be seriously exposed to one or more of the following threats that can arise years after you depart.
For instance, the beneficiary’s spouse may snatch half (or more) of the inherited IRA’s in a divorce. The divorce rate is over 50% and a big pile of inherited money may become a divorce incentive for the ex-spouse. Even though inherited property is separate property, the beneficiary’s ex-spouse’s divorce lawyer will probably go after the IRA funds because the IRA account is frequently the largest asset and the lawyer knows there is a good chance the spouse who inherited the IRA will give a large portion or all of the IRA account just to end the divorce and to be rid of the ex-spouse.
Your beneficiary may have poor spending habits; have creditors and lawsuits that can grab all of the inherited IRA proceeds.
Your beneficiary could lose his or her needs-based government benefits (if he or she ever requires them), such as supplemental income (SSI) or long-term nursing care.
Even if your beneficiary never encounters any of these problems, he or she may get walloped with a huge estate tax when they pass the IRA down to the next generation.
One of the big advantages to the IRA Beneficiary Trust® is the option to give a “Special Trustee” the right to elect out of a straight “conduit-trust” (i.e., where the “Mandatory Retirement Distribution (MRD) must be paid to the beneficiary on an annual basis) to a fully discretionary “accumulation trust” (i.e., where the trustee can hold the beneficiary’s MRD inside the trust). This election must be made, if at all, by September 30 of the year following the client’s death. Making this election may result in a shorter “stretch-out” because the age of the oldest “possible beneficiary” must be used (the Special Trustee is also given the power to limit such possible beneficiaries to minimize this issue); however, having this option to elect between the different forms of trusts provides the flexibility to consider all factors known at the time of death and up to the election deadline (e.g., creditor problems, disability, etc.) which may greatly out-weigh the increase in the income tax costs.
If you have a reasonable IRA you want to pass down or don’t think you’ll need to live on your IRA you absolutely should be thinking about this strategy.
Please contact my law office to get this in place for you and your family as it can make the difference between leaving a legacy and leaving a time-bomb.
Untaxingly,
James Burns, Esq.